Fri Feb 10 2012
Departments
National Issues

Congressman Payne: I won't oppose war money because Obama's president
by David Swanson
February 1, 2010

Congressman Donald Payne (D., N.J.) has voted against war funding bills for years. Last summer he was one of 32 heroes to vote No under intense pressure from the White House to vote Yes. When I asked him a couple of years ago to sign onto impeaching Bush he immediately said "Sure!" and he did it.

Today I asked him if he would commit to voting No on the next $33 billion for war. I asked him privately, just after he'd given a long speech to a Progressive Democrats of America conference in New Jersey, a speech about how much he opposes the wars.

Payne told me that he didn't want to commit to voting No on the next "emergency war supplemental" because Obama is president, echoing Jan Schakowsky's comments last June when she made a similar reversal.

"Congressman Payne," I said, "aren't the bombs the same? Isn't the dying the same?" He agreed and told me I was preaching to the choir.

"And is the only difference that a different person is president?" I asked. "Yes," he replied.

When I had prefaced my question with praising him for standing strong last June, I had referenced the major promises and threats that other congressmembers had reported receiving from the White House. Payne said he had experienced the same. Yet somehow he had resisted, but is unsure about resisting further.

Earlier in the day, another Democratic congressman from New Jersey, Frank Pallone, had spoken to the PDA conference, and both PDA's national director Tim Carpenter and I had asked him publicly to commit to voting No on the war money.

I thanked Pallone for voting No on war supplementals in 2004 and 2005 and expressed disappointment that he had voted Yes last June. He refused to commit to voting No, with the excuse that something good might be attached to the war money. Yet he had voted No in the past, despite the fact that good hard-to-oppose measures were always applied as lipstick on these bills.

Was Pallone's real thinking that he wanted to obey the president? I can't say for sure, but I can say that he took a lot of questions from PDA members about his positions, and he tended to answer by explaining what Obama's positions are. And I can say that Pallone raised lots of rightwing reasons for not being stronger on issues like healthcare, and other members of the panel he was part of decisively refuted each point but had no impact on the congressman's position whatsoever.

Joining Pallone on the panel were Carpenter and PDA board member Steve Cobble, Co-Chair of PDA's Healthcare Not Warfare campaign Donna Smith, and the president of the New Jersey Industrial Union Council Ray Stever. They laid out the case and the strategy for shifting our resources from wars to human needs, especially single-payer healthcare.

The conference rooms were packed, and everyone involved was eager to get to work, including a lot of people new to PDA's organizing. Joanne O'Neil and the other leaders of New Jersey PDA were pleased with the conference, but far from satisfied with the positions of the two congress members who attended.

To their credit, however, everyone was focused on lobbying, challenging, and pressuring until their representatives agree to represent the people of New Jersey rather than taking their orders from a president who has three more years in office even if his followers get themselves voted out this November.

I expect more congress members from New Jersey, possibly even Payne and Pallone, to be joining those committed to voting No on the wars they claim to oppose: http://defundwar.org

---
David Swanson is the author of the new book "Daybreak: Undoing the Imperial Presidency and Forming a More Perfect Union" by Seven Stories Press. You can order it and find out when tour will be in your town: http://davidswanson.org/book.


Recent National Issues Articles

A Year of fall and decline
  December 28, 2010
  David Swanson

2011: Year of resistance
  December 22, 2010
  David Swanson

Antiwar protest at White House
  December 17, 2010
  Pete Johnson

Transcending progressive discord
  December 16, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

Richard Holbrooke's deathbed conversion
  December 15, 2010
  David Swanson

Obama wooing “Economic Royalists”
  November 20, 2010
  Norman Solomon

The Republican war on reality
  October 29, 2010
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Such is the peace process: Obama as a salesman
  October 28, 2010
  Ramzy Baroud

Rules of play
  October 23, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

Leakers, Beware the Corporate Media
  October 14, 2010
  Ray McGovern

An open letter to Barack Obama
  October 13, 2010
  Paul Krassner

Stop the anonymous hit men: make shadowy campaign money the issue
  October 12, 2010
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Don't let the Russ Feingolds go down for the sins of the Blanche Lincolns
  October 6, 2010
  Paul Rogat Loeb

No, higher consciousness won’t save us
  September 23, 2010
  Norman Solomon

Triumph of the Money Party!!! Warren's role downgraded, reports to Geithner
  September 16, 2010
  Michael Collins

Wall Street's Mercenaries Ride Donkeys
  September 14, 2010
  David Swanson

Right-wing Republicans vs. corporate Democrats vs. progressive populists
  September 10, 2010
  Norman Solomon

Five years and still drowning: The New Orleans CNN would never show you
  August 25, 2010
  Greg Palast

See something, say something
  August 19, 2010
  James Hanson

An honest look at Obama's first year
  August 9, 2010
  David Swanson

Let's give country reason to celebrate
  August 9, 2010
  Rev. Jesse Jackson

Revenge of the weeds
  July 15, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

Holding Psychologists accountable for Torture
  July 8, 2010
  Terry Lodge

Confronting rendition to torture in North Carolina
  July 7, 2010
  Clare Hanrahan, WarIsACrime.org

Witnessing against torture: Why we must act
  June 23, 2010
  Kathy Kelly, WarIsACrime.org

An easy way to dramatically change Congress
  June 22, 2010
  David Swanson

Ten suggestions for effective activism
  June 18, 2010
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Inauguration Day 2013
  June 15, 2010
  Ted Sylvester

California's Prop. 14: A bad deal for democracy
  June 6, 2010
  Norman Solomon

The learning curve of peace
  May 25, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

U.S. laws rated worst value per dollar
  May 23, 2010
  David Swanson

Getting smart about stupid communication
  May 17, 2010
  David Swanson

Chevron's "crude" attempt to suppress free speech
  May 16, 2010
  Bill Moyers and Michael Winship

Afghan escalation funding: More war, fewer jobs, poor excuses
  May 11, 2010
  David Swanson

Kagan in context: Shafting progressive values
  May 10, 2010
  Norman Solomon

12 fresh angles on the Gulf Coast oil spill, neatly packaged
  May 3, 2010
  Tod Brilliant

Massey and Goldman under criminal investigation
  May 1, 2010
  David Swanson

50 years later the struggle continues
  April 29, 2010
  Saul Landau

Iran a Threat? I Mean, Really?
  April 27, 2010
  Ray McGovern

Investigate the case of Mumia Abu-Jamal
  April 25, 2010
  Dr. Suzanne Ross (917) 584-2135 • Pam Africa (215) 476-8812

A mad Tea Party
  April 23, 2010
  Helen Werner Cox and John Werner Cox

Journey of a citizen
  April 22, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

Who let the Blue Dogs out?
  April 21, 2010
  Norman Solomon

Our national epidemic of violence
  April 21, 2010
  David Swanson

Tea Party and rail discussion
  April 17, 2010
  Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman

Mines have spurned safety for too long
  April 16, 2010
  Rev. Jesse L. Jackson Sr.

Kucinich on assassinations and upcoming war funding vote
  April 16, 2010
  David Swanson

Yeah, well you finally stopped getting mad
  April 15, 2010
  David Swanson

Peace activists extend an olive branch to the Tea Party to talk about war
  April 14, 2010
  Medea Benjamin

Corporatocracy and its discontents
  April 13, 2010
  David Swanson

Our national epidemic of violence
  April 13, 2010
  David Swanson

How the corporations broke Ralph Nader and America, too
  April 8, 2010
  Chris Hedges

Citizens united against Citizens United
  March 27, 2010
  David Swanson

Frank Olson, Enemy Combatant
  March 26, 2010
  David Swanson

Lies, damn lies, and the media
  March 23, 2010
  David Swanson

United States Hypocrisy Knows No Rationale - take it to the UN
  March 21, 2010
  Jim Miles

'Soul Of A Citizen' excerpt: taking money out of politics: a grassroots effort for clean elections
  March 20, 2010
  Paul Rogat Loeb

John Yoo: a president can nuke the United States
  March 20, 2010
  David Swanson

The GITMO distraction
  March 18, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

How the Democrats can reclaim the youth vote
  March 17, 2010
  Paul Rogat Loeb

I'm Down With Dennis
  March 15, 2010
  david swanson

Bob Fitrakis and Harvey Wasserman on WCRS Radio
  March 13, 2010
  Tom Over

Dear Eric Holder: Try accused criminals in courts of law
  March 11, 2010
  The Robert Jackson Steering Committee

Jay Bybee questioned as prelude to prosecution
  March 6, 2010
  David Swanson

Whirlpool in Evansville
  March 5, 2010
  Jason Perlman, Communications Director, Ohio AFL-CIO

Paradise lost
  March 5, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

Does DOJ agree with Yoo on testicles, villages, and nukes?
  February 27, 2010
  David Swanson

Pre-partisan America, 1789-1801
  February 25, 2010
  David Swanson

Yoo, Bybee, and disinformation
  February 21, 2010
  David Swanson

Activists protest Dr. Larry James and torture at Wright State
  February 9, 2010
  Pete Johnson

Feb. 6 Statement by Leonard Peltier
  February 7, 2010
  Leonard Peltier

Kvetcher in the Rye
  February 5, 2010
  Greg Palast

On war, conformity, the Democratic Party and progressive possibilities
  February 5, 2010
  Norman Solomon

Top 10 problems with America assassinating Americans
  February 5, 2010
  David Swanson

Blocking war funding just got easier
  February 4, 2010
  David Swanson

Congressman Payne: I won't oppose war money because Obama's president
  February 1, 2010
  David Swanson

The source of corporate power
  January 30, 2010
  Robert C. Koehler

Fixing a bad Supreme Court decision
  January 29, 2010
  Joel S. Hirschhorn

Give to the Congress information of the State of the Union
  January 29, 2010
  David Swanson

Gone a week and you trash the country
  January 28, 2010
  David Swanson

Et Tu, ACLU?
  January 27, 2010
  Bob Fitrakis & Harvey Wasserman

PUBLIC INTEREST GROUPS CONDEMN SUPREME COURT'S RULING ON CORPORATE MONEY IN ELECTIONS
  January 22, 2010
  David Swanson

A fable for our time
  January 15, 2010
  David Swanson

Northwest Bomb Plot 'Oddities'
  January 13, 2010
  Lori Price

Good News: Will We Hear It?
  January 11, 2010
  David Swanson

Calling the bluff in the Conference Committee
  January 11, 2010
  Paul Rogat Loeb

Naked empire
  January 7, 2010
  Saul Landau

Recommended new year's resolutions for all Americans
  January 1, 2010
  Bruce Arnold

Are Presidents Afraid of the CIA?
  January 1, 2010
  Ray McGovern




Read National Issues Articles by Year:
2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 2001 2000



FREE PRESS EMAIL UPDATE


Donate to The Free Press The Free Press Store

FOLLOW US ON
twitter
facebook


SEARCH THE FREEPRESS




1021 E. Broad St. Columbus, OH 43205 | 614.253.2571 | truth@freepress.org
All content © 1970-2012 The Columbus Free Press
Disclaimer